Joanna Gaines’ Baklava Recipe Review: Unlocking the Secrets to a Flaky & Flavorful Dessert

Joanna Gaines’ recipe for Baklava, meticulously crafted from her celebrated Magnolia Table Cookbook Vol. 2, is truly exceptional and stands out as a must-try for any baking enthusiast. As a professional chef, I’ve always viewed Baklava, with its delicate layers and rich culinary heritage, as a somewhat formidable challenge. My initial foray into making Baklava from scratch, before discovering Joanna’s rendition, was a rewarding experience, proving it was more approachable than I first imagined. However, when I first perused Joanna’s specific recipe, the intricate steps and the sheer volume of phyllo dough involved initially felt a little daunting. Despite this, I can confidently attest that any initial apprehension quickly dissipates once you embark on the baking journey. This recipe is not just achievable; it delivers an absolutely awesome, authentic experience that will undoubtedly impress even the most discerning palates with its perfect blend of sweetness, crunch, and aroma.

A Chef’s Detailed Review of the Baklava Making Process

While Joanna’s recipe is indeed remarkable for its straightforward approach and ease of execution, I did encounter one minor point of contention right from the start, particularly concerning the phyllo dough quantities. For those of us using standard store-bought phyllo dough, readily available in most supermarkets, the layer counts prescribed in the recipe simply do not align perfectly with the typical package size. I found myself with a frustrating five extra sheets of delicate phyllo dough at the end of the layering process. The dilemma then arises: what to do with these remaining, fragile sheets? Rather than face the waste or the fussy task of attempting to re-wrap them for a nebulous future use, I made a spontaneous decision to simply continue layering them into the baklava. This improvisation, I must say, ultimately resulted in an even more glorious, multi-layered dessert, adding to its luxurious texture.

My strong recommendation for anyone preparing this delightful recipe would be to proactively add two extra sheets of phyllo dough to each major layering step. This simple adjustment ensures you utilize the entire package of dough, thereby preventing any wasteful leftovers and simultaneously creating an even more luxuriously flaky baklava. It’s a significant personal pet peeve of mine when recipes lead to unusable quantities of ingredients, so this minor tweak makes the entire baking process feel much more satisfying and complete.

Beyond this small adjustment, the recipe flows beautifully. I never felt rushed or pressured in the kitchen, which is often a significant concern when working with delicate ingredients such as phyllo. Preparing the nuts and melting the butter takes only a few minutes, and while the layering process with phyllo dough demands a certain pace to prevent the sheets from drying out and becoming brittle, you quickly develop a comfortable rhythm. The repetitive motion of brushing butter and meticulously placing layers becomes almost meditative, transforming what could be perceived as a stressful task into a genuinely fun and surprisingly relaxing culinary endeavor. The immense satisfaction derived from watching those golden layers build up, promising a delicious outcome, is truly immense.

A crucial component that elevates any exceptional baklava is its accompanying syrup. While the initial focus rightly remains on the intricate layering of phyllo and nuts, preparing the fragrant, sweet syrup either concurrently or just as the baklava finishes baking is absolutely essential. This syrup, typically a carefully balanced blend of sugar, water, often with a hint of lemon juice or honey, and infused with delightful spices like cinnamon sticks or cloves, is what truly transforms the pastry. Ensuring the syrup is at the correct temperature – often hot syrup poured over cold baklava, or vice-versa, depending on the desired final texture – is paramount to achieving that perfect balance of crispness and moist, sweet indulgence. Joanna’s recipe, like all exemplary baklava recipes, thoughtfully accounts for this critical step, ensuring a harmonious and profoundly satisfying finish.

The Unforgettable Reaction: Love at First Crunch

There are truly not enough superlatives to adequately capture the sheer delight and overwhelming success this baklava brought to my household. This recipe didn’t just pass; it soared through the ultimate family taste test with overwhelmingly flying colors. There was a palpable sense of anticipation and excitement that built up as I meticulously prepared it, and the hype before that first bite was immense. Thankfully, the baklava didn’t just live up to the hype; it spectacularly exceeded it, delivering an unforgettable culinary experience that transcended all expectations.

I believe it was unequivocally love at first crunch. The moment the delicate, buttery layers of phyllo met the teeth, followed by the rich, spiced nut filling and the sweet, aromatic embrace of the syrup, I found myself pausing, genuinely questioning if I had ever truly experienced fresh, homemade baklava of this caliber before. The immediate crispness, followed by an intense, complex flavor profile that gently perfumes your palate and lingers delightfully, is nothing short of heavenly. It’s a magnificent symphony of textures and tastes – the fragile crackle of the golden phyllo, the satisfying, slightly chewy texture of the perfectly chopped nuts, and the warm, sweet embrace of the aromatic syrup. This baklava isn’t merely a dessert; it’s an immersive experience, a delightful journey for the senses that left everyone, including myself, craving just one more piece.

Often, commercially produced or even some less carefully made homemade baklava can be overly sweet, greasy, or disappointingly lacking in the distinct, defined layers that are the hallmark of this classic pastry. Joanna’s recipe, however, strikes an absolutely perfect balance. The sweetness is beautifully present but never cloying, allowing the fragrant notes of the nuts and the richness of the butter to truly shine. The inherent freshness of the homemade phyllo (or well-handled store-bought phyllo) makes an enormous difference, contributing to a delightful lightness that makes it dangerously easy to enjoy multiple pieces without feeling overwhelmed. This baklava feels authentic, handcrafted, and utterly delicious.

Essential Tips for Perfecting Your Joanna Gaines Baklava

As I passionately emphasized earlier, do not let any phyllo dough go to waste! When you’re using standard supermarket phyllo, ensure you utilize the entire package. My strong recommendation is to add two extra sheets to each major layer, creating an even more luxuriantly flaky and substantial baklava. This simple yet effective adjustment not only prevents frustrating leftovers but also significantly enhances the texture, making each bite incredibly satisfying, buttery, and exceptionally delicate. It truly won’t negatively impact the outcome; instead, it promises a superior, extra-flaky dessert that will surely bring joy to anyone who tastes it, and to my chef’s heart, knowing no precious dough has been needlessly discarded.

Handling Phyllo Dough Like a Pro

Working with phyllo dough can seem intimidating at first glance due to its delicate nature, but a key tip for success is to always keep it covered with a slightly damp (not wet!) kitchen towel while you are not actively working with it. This crucial step prevents the ultra-thin sheets from drying out and becoming brittle, which would make them prone to tearing. While a certain speed and confidence in layering are beneficial, keeping the phyllo properly moisturized with a damp towel is truly your best friend throughout the process, ensuring smooth and flawless execution.

My Preferred Cutting Method for Elegant Portions

Before embarking on this baklava adventure, I consulted a few additional baklava recipes and guides. Joanna’s suggested cutting method, while likely effective, seemed a little too intricate and time-consuming for my personal preference in the kitchen. My chosen approach, which consistently yielded beautiful, restaurant-quality slices, involves first cutting the entire layered baklava into four long, even strips directly in the baking pan. Then, starting from the corners, I proceed to slice diagonally across these strips. This method effortlessly creates elegant diamond or triangle shapes that are both visually appealing and perfectly portioned for serving. The resulting “restaurant-style” slices truly enhanced the overall presentation, and I thoroughly enjoyed the refined look they offered.

It is absolutely crucial to cut the baklava *before* you bake it. This fundamental step is often overlooked by novices but is absolutely vital for a successful outcome. Cutting it pre-bake prevents the delicate, cooked phyllo layers from crumbling excessively when you attempt to slice them after they’ve become crisp. More importantly, pre-cutting allows the hot syrup to penetrate evenly into all the layers and crevices during the pouring stage, ensuring every single piece is perfectly infused, deliciously moist, and utterly irresistible.

Yield, Storage, and Enjoyment

This recipe produces a generously sized batch of baklava, which is wonderful, especially considering how incredibly rich and sweet this traditional pastry is. You’ll have plenty to share with friends and family, or to savor over an extended period. For optimal storage and to maintain its delightful crispness, baklava keeps beautifully at room temperature. Simply place it in an airtight container on your kitchen counter, and it will remain wonderfully flaky and fresh for up to two weeks. The airtight seal is key to preserving its delightful texture and preventing it from drying out. If you anticipate not devouring it quite so quickly, or if you simply prefer a slightly different consistency, you can store it in the refrigerator. Refrigerated baklava tends to become a bit softer and chewier, offering a different but equally delicious experience.

For long-term preservation, baklava freezes exceptionally well, allowing you to enjoy it weeks or even months later. To freeze, wrap the entire container tightly in a double layer of plastic wrap, followed by a double layer of heavy-duty aluminum foil. This robust wrapping protects the baklava from freezer burn and helps maintain its quality. It can be safely frozen for up to three months without compromising its exquisite flavor or texture. When you’re ready to indulge, simply thaw the baklava at room temperature for approximately 4-5 hours, or gently transfer it to the refrigerator overnight to defrost slowly.

Mastering the Layering Chant: Joanna’s Method, Kendell’s Twist

If you had the pleasure of watching the episode where Joanna Gaines demonstrated this baklava recipe on her show, you’ll undoubtedly recall she devised a clever and memorable chant to help her remember the precise layering sequence without constantly referring back to the cookbook. Her handy mantra was: “6, nut, 6, nut, 6, nut, 10.” This is indeed a very useful mnemonic! However, as I highlighted earlier, if you’re using standard phyllo dough from your local supermarket, you’ll need to adapt this chant slightly to account for the typical package size. I recommend updating her chant to: “8, nut, 8, nut, 8, nut, ALL THE REST!” This ensures you efficiently use up all those precious sheets of phyllo and ultimately end up with a magnificent, thick, and perfectly layered dessert that truly maximizes the deliciousness.

Nuts and Spices: Elevating Your Baklava

When it comes to the nuts, the recipe typically calls for walnuts, which provide a classic, rich flavor. However, don’t hesitate to experiment and customize! A delightful mix of walnuts and pistachios, or even almonds, can introduce different dimensions of flavor and texture, making your baklava uniquely yours. It’s important to ensure your nuts are finely chopped but not pulverized into a powder; you want to retain some textural bite. Furthermore, incorporating a touch of ground cinnamon or even a hint of ground cloves mixed directly with the nuts can significantly enhance the aroma and introduce warm, inviting spice notes, making your baklava even more irresistible and complex. These small additions can truly elevate a great recipe to an extraordinary one.

Overall, Joanna Gaines’ Baklava recipe is an absolute triumph and has undoubtedly earned its place as a permanent “keeper” in my culinary repertoire. It strikes that perfect balance of being simple enough to execute without feeling overwhelmed by complexity, yet it’s impressive enough to “show out” and present a truly spectacular dessert for guests or any special occasion. While it does require a couple of pots for preparing the syrup and melting the butter, the minimal clean-up afterward, especially for a dessert of this caliber, makes it even more appealing. The effort invested is undeniably worth it for the incredible reward of a homemade baklava that rivals any pastry shop in terms of flavor, texture, and sheer deliciousness.

Until next time, Happy Cooking!

Kendell

If you watched Joanna make this recipe on Season 1, Episode 1 of her new cooking show ‘Magnolia Table with Joanna Gaines‘ you can get the recipe by CLICKING HERE, she shared it on her blog so you can make it at home!

–

READ MY OTHER REVIEWS OF EPISODE 1 HERE…

White Bean Hummus

Jo’s Fatayar and Lebanese Salad

Get the shallow 9×13-inch pan you see in my photos here!

Did you make this recipe? Let me know by leaving a review or comment! And be sure to sign up for my newsletter, and follow along on Instagram, Pinterest, and Facebook!