Contents

The Ultimate Custard French Toast: Perfectly Caramelized with Cinnamon Sugar

Embark on a culinary quest for the holy grail of breakfast foods, and you’ll find yourself searching for the perfect French toast. After countless experiments and taste tests, I can confidently declare that this Custard French Toast, featuring a divine caramelized cinnamon sugar crust, stands head and shoulders above the rest. It’s not just the best I’ve ever made; it’s quite possibly the most exquisite French toast I’ve ever had the pleasure of tasting! Prepare to transform your morning meal into an unforgettable gourmet experience that will have you craving it repeatedly.

Finished Custard French Toast, generously sprinkled with caramelized cinnamon sugar, adorned with a pat of melting butter, and beautifully drizzled with rich maple syrup.

[feast_advanced_jump_to]

What Makes This The Absolute Best French Toast?

For me, the pinnacle of French toast perfection lies in a delicate balance: a crisp, slightly crunchy exterior giving way to an incredibly soft, luscious, custard-like center. It should evoke the luxurious experience of enjoying crème brûlée for breakfast, offering a textural contrast that delights with every bite. The secret weapon that truly elevates this recipe from merely good to absolutely sublime is the caramelization of the cinnamon sugar on the toast’s surface. This magical touch creates an irresistible crust that locks in moisture and adds a complex, sweet, and slightly spiced flavor that is simply unparalleled.

Achieving this heavenly harmony requires adherence to a few non-negotiable techniques. Firstly, and perhaps most crucially, you MUST use only egg yolks in your custard base. This seemingly small detail is monumental. Omitting egg whites prevents the custard from becoming “eggy” or developing a rubbery texture. Instead, the yolks contribute an unparalleled richness and silkiness, ensuring the bread’s interior transforms into a thick, flavorful, and truly custardy delight, free from any hint of gloopy, undercooked egg white.

Secondly, the cooking fat is key. To ensure each slice is perfectly browned, rich in flavor, and never burnt, you have to cook the toast in a combination of vegetable oil and unsalted butter. The butter imparts a deep, nutty flavor and a beautiful golden hue, while the oil, with its higher smoke point, provides stability and prevents the butter from burning too quickly. This dynamic duo guarantees a consistent, even cook and a superior taste.

Finally, for that signature crisp and caramelized finish, a meticulous sugaring process is essential. Each side of the dipped brioche is generously dusted with cinnamon sugar, then cooked and flipped multiple times. This technique allows the sugar to melt and caramelize, forming a delectable, crunchy glaze. Start with medium-low heat to gently set the custard through the bread’s core, ensuring it cooks evenly without scorching. Then, towards the end, increase the heat to medium. This crucial temperature adjustment is what transforms the cinnamon sugar into a glistening, golden-brown crust, delivering that coveted crunch and deeply satisfying caramelized flavor. Follow these detailed steps, and you are guaranteed to create the most delicious, perfectly custardy, and exquisitely caramelized French toast you have ever experienced.

Close-up of finished Custard French Toast, featuring a rich, golden-brown crust, dusted with cinnamon sugar, and ready to be served.

Use the JUMP TO RECIPE button at the top of the post, or scroll to the bottom of the post to see the full recipe card with ingredient measurements and instructions.

Essential Ingredients for Unforgettable French Toast

A selection of fresh ingredients laid out, including eggs, cream, vanilla, cinnamon, sugar, and a loaf of brioche bread, all ready for making French Toast.

This remarkable recipe relies on a surprisingly short list of simple ingredients, but it’s the quality and combination of a few key players that truly elevate it from good to absolutely phenomenal. The star of the show, without a doubt, is the brioche bread. Brioche is the superior choice for French toast due to its rich, buttery flavor and tender, airy crumb. Its high fat and egg content means it can absorb the custard without becoming soggy, providing the perfect foundation for that luscious, custardy interior. It’s this specific bread that transforms a regular breakfast into a crave-worthy culinary delight.

Beyond the bread, I’m a firm believer in the power of quality dairy. This recipe specifically calls for a blend of heavy cream and half-and-half. This combination is essential for creating a thick, luxurious custard that truly infuses the brioche, contributing significantly to the desired texture and richness. While other milks might work in a pinch, they simply won’t achieve the depth of flavor and creamy consistency that makes this Custard French Toast undeniably THE BEST! The fat content in the cream and half-and-half also contributes to the golden-brown crust when cooked, working in harmony with the egg yolks for an unparalleled flavor and texture.

Furthermore, the use of only egg yolks, as previously discussed, is critical. They provide the necessary emulsification and richness without the watery or “eggy” notes sometimes associated with whole eggs. A good quality vanilla extract is also indispensable, adding a warm, aromatic depth that complements the sweetness. And of course, the cinnamon sugar – a blend of granulated sugar and ground cinnamon – is not just for dusting; a touch is whisked into the custard itself, weaving its fragrant magic throughout every bite. Don’t forget the unsalted butter and vegetable oil for cooking, and a generous pour of pure maple syrup for serving. Each ingredient plays a vital role in crafting this exquisite breakfast experience, so choosing quality makes all the difference.

A stack of perfectly cooked Custard French Toast slices, caramelized with cinnamon sugar, topped with a dollop of butter and a drizzle of maple syrup, invitingly presented.

Crafting the Perfect Caramelized Custard French Toast

Let’s dive into the step-by-step process for creating this incredible French toast. Precision and technique are key to achieving that perfect crisp, custardy, and caramelized result.

Step 1: Prepare Your Cinnamon Sugar. Begin by making your signature cinnamon sugar blend. In a small bowl, combine 1 cup of granulated sugar with 1 tablespoon of ground cinnamon. For an extra layer of warmth and complexity, you can also add ¼ teaspoon of ground nutmeg and ½ teaspoon of kosher salt to this mixture – these additions truly elevate the flavor profile. Whisk everything together thoroughly until well combined. Transfer this fragrant mixture into a sugar shaker or an empty spice jar with large holes. Having it in a shaker makes for effortless and even dusting during the cooking process. I always keep a bottle of this “Cinna-dust,” as we call it, on hand; it’s fantastic for topping oatmeal, fruit, or even coffee!

Step 2: Whisk the Custard Base. In a large, shallow dish or bowl (wide enough to accommodate a slice of bread), combine the egg yolks, vanilla extract, half-and-half, heavy cream, and 2 tablespoons of your prepared cinnamon sugar. Whisk these ingredients together vigorously until the mixture is well combined, slightly frothy, and takes on a smooth, uniform custard consistency. Ensure there are no streaks of unmixed ingredients.

Step 3: Prepare the Pan and Soak the Bread. Heat a 10-12 inch non-stick skillet or griddle over medium-low heat. Add 1 teaspoon of vegetable oil and ½ tablespoon of unsalted butter to the pan. Allow the butter to melt and foam gently, swirling to coat the pan evenly. While the pan heats, take one slice of thick-cut brioche bread and dip it into the custard mixture. Allow it to soak for 20-30 seconds per side, gently turning it over 3-4 times. The goal is to fully saturate the bread with the custard without letting it become completely waterlogged and prone to crumbling. It should feel heavy but still hold its shape.

Detailed shot of whisking egg yolks, heavy cream, half and half, and vanilla extract with cinnamon sugar in a bowl, creating the French toast custard base.

A slice of brioche bread being carefully dipped and submerged into the rich, frothy custard mixture in a shallow dish, ensuring even saturation.

Step 4: Cook and Caramelize. Gently place two saturated slices of brioche into the heated skillet, ensuring they don’t overcrowd the pan. Immediately dust the top surface of each slice generously with your cinnamon sugar mixture. Cook on medium-low heat for about 3-4 minutes, or until the bottom side is a beautiful golden brown and the custard begins to set. Carefully flip the toast over, sugar-side down. Now, dust the newly exposed cooked side with more cinnamon sugar. Continue cooking for another 3-4 minutes until this second side is also golden and the sugar begins to caramelize, creating a gorgeous crust. If needed, turn the heat up slightly to medium after the first flip to encourage optimal caramelization of the sugar. This higher heat helps the sugar melt and brown without burning the bread.

Two slices of French Toast cooking in a skillet, with the first side turning golden brown and the second side lightly dusted with cinnamon sugar, preparing for the flip.

One slice of French Toast flipped in the pan, revealing a perfectly golden and caramelized underside, with the top side now dusted with cinnamon sugar, continuing to cook.

Step 5: Finish and Serve. Once both sides have developed that beautiful golden, caramelized cinnamon sugar crust, remove the toast from the pan. Repeat the soaking and cooking process with the remaining brioche slices, adding more oil and butter to the pan as needed for each new batch. To keep earlier batches warm while you finish cooking, you can place them on a baking sheet in a preheated oven set to its lowest temperature (around 200°F / 95°C). The end result should be slices of French toast that boast a delightful crispness and sweetness on the outside, perfectly contrasting with an incredibly soft, rich, and custardy interior.

For the ultimate presentation and flavor, serve your freshly cooked French toast immediately. Garnish each serving with an additional dusting of cinnamon sugar, a luxurious pat of unsalted butter that melts into the warm toast, and a generous drizzle of pure maple syrup. Prepare for a breakfast revelation!

A close-up of a stack of caramelized Custard French Toast slices, elegantly topped with a square of melting butter and glistening with maple syrup.

Expert Notes & Tips for Flawless French Toast

Achieving French toast perfection is all about understanding the nuances of the ingredients and techniques. Here are some invaluable notes and tips to ensure your success:

Choosing Your Bread: While I wholeheartedly recommend thick-cut brioche, particularly a loaf like the one found at Trader Joe’s (which often comes pre-sliced at the ideal thickness), you can certainly use other brioche varieties. The key is to slice it yourself to an optimal thickness of 1 to 1.5 inches. This ensures maximum custard absorption without the bread falling apart. Other excellent bread choices for French toast include Challah (similarly rich and eggy), Sourdough (offering a delightful tang and sturdy texture), or traditional French bread. For Sourdough or French bread, make sure it’s a day or two old; slightly stale bread absorbs the custard better without turning mushy.
Mastering the Soak: There is a precise sweet spot when it comes to soaking your bread in the custard. Too little time, and the center will be dry and uninspired. Too much, and the bread will become overly saturated, resembling a sponge that crumbles in your hand, leading to a soggy, unsatisfying cooked result. The recommended 20-30 seconds with 3-4 gentle flips is the magic window. This allows the brioche to absorb just enough of the rich custard to become incredibly moist and custardy in the middle when cooked, without losing its structural integrity.
Don’t Overcrowd the Pan: Cooking French toast in batches, typically two slices at a time in a 10-12 inch skillet, is crucial. Overcrowding the pan lowers the temperature, steaming the bread instead of browning it, and prevents that desired crisp exterior and even caramelization.
Keep Warm: As you cook subsequent batches, keep the already cooked French toast warm. A great way to do this is to transfer them to a wire rack set over a baking sheet and place them in a preheated oven at its lowest setting (around 200°F or 95°C). This keeps them hot and slightly crispy without overcooking.
Serve Immediately: French toast is best enjoyed fresh off the pan. The contrast between the warm, custardy interior and the crisp, caramelized exterior is at its peak immediately after cooking.
Make-Ahead Components: While fresh is best, you can prepare the cinnamon sugar mixture days in advance. The custard base can also be whisked together and stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 24 hours, making breakfast prep much quicker on busy mornings.

A close-up shot of a single slice of finished Custard French Toast, emphasizing its perfectly golden, caramelized crust and soft, inviting texture.

Versatile Substitutions for Your Custard French Toast

While this recipe is crafted for optimal results, understanding potential substitutions allows for flexibility and caters to various dietary needs or ingredient availability:

Dairy-Free Alternatives: The richness of this recipe primarily stems from the egg yolks and heavy cream. However, you can adapt it to be dairy-free. Substitute the half-and-half and heavy cream with full-fat alternative milks such as almond milk, cashew milk, or oat milk (ensure they are unsweetened for best control of sweetness). For cooking, replace butter with coconut oil, a plant-based butter alternative, or simply use only vegetable oil. While the flavor profile will differ slightly, it can still yield a delicious result.
Brioche Replacements: If brioche is unavailable or if you prefer a different base, excellent alternatives include sourdough bread, French bread (baguette or pain de campagne), or Challah bread. When using these, it’s best to buy a whole loaf and slice it yourself to achieve the desired 1 to 1.5-inch thickness. Slightly stale bread (day-old) works particularly well as it holds its structure and absorbs the custard without becoming too mushy.
Vanilla Extract Substitutions: If you find yourself out of vanilla extract, there are several flavorful alternatives. You can use vanilla-flavored milk (almond or soy), a touch of pure maple syrup (it has a complementary flavor), or even a splash of alcohol like bourbon, rum, or brandy. Many vanilla extracts are alcohol-based, and these spirits carry enough flavor to mimic and even enhance the vanilla notes. A hint of bourbon or brandy in French toast can be truly extraordinary!
Maple Syrup Alternatives: While pure maple syrup is the traditional and arguably best accompaniment, don’t hesitate to explore other toppings if you’re out or simply want variety. A vibrant berry compote (made from fresh or frozen raspberries, blueberries, or strawberries), a dollop of fruit jam, a generous swirl of whipped cream, a dusting of powdered sugar, or even a drizzle of chocolate or caramel sauce can provide a delightful finishing touch.

A beautifully composed shot of the finished Custard French Toast, rich in color and texture, presented with a side of maple syrup and ready to be enjoyed.

More Breakfast Favorites to Explore

If you loved this French toast, be sure to check out these other delightful breakfast recipes from my collection!

Pumpkin Spice Pancakes

Savory Breakfast Focaccia

Homemade Peach Jelly Donuts

Chunky Vanilla Almond Granola

Did you make this incredible Custard French Toast recipe? I’d love to hear about it! Please leave a review or comment below to share your experience. And don’t forget to sign up for my newsletter for more delicious recipes and kitchen tips. You can also follow along on Instagram, Pinterest, and Facebook to stay connected!

📖 Recipe

Yield: 9-10 slices