Mastering Joanna Gaines’ Jojo’s Biscuits: An In-Depth Review and Pro Tips for Achieving Perfect Fluffy Biscuits

The moment I first discovered Joanna Gaines’ Jojo’s Biscuits recipe, I was absolutely captivated. The backstory, shared within the pages of the Magnolia Table Cookbook Vol. 1, tells of Joanna’s meticulous year-long journey, dedicating countless Saturdays to perfecting this single recipe. This dedication immediately spoke to me, transforming Jojo’s Biscuits into more than just a dish—it became a culinary quest. There was no question in my mind: this iconic recipe had to be the very first one I tackled from her highly anticipated cookbook. The allure of fluffy, homemade biscuits, especially those with such a rich origin story, was simply irresistible, promising a taste of that beloved Magnolia charm right in my own kitchen.

My initial enthusiasm, however, was met with a slight hurdle. The recipe specifically calls for self-rising flour, an ingredient I rarely, if ever, stocked in my pantry. This meant a delayed start, a testament to my eagerness as I patiently awaited my next grocery run. But necessity, as they say, is the mother of invention. This minor inconvenience spurred me to action, prompting me to learn the art of crafting my own homemade self-rising flour blend. This simple revelation transformed my biscuit-making routine entirely. Now, the magic of Jojo’s Biscuits is always within reach, allowing me to whip up a batch whenever the craving strikes, without the need for an impromptu store visit. I’m so excited about this discovery that I’ve included my go-to recipe for Homemade Self-Rising Flour at the very end of this comprehensive review, ensuring you too can enjoy spontaneous biscuit baking.

Below, you’ll find my detailed review and personal journey with this celebrated recipe. It’s important to note that achieving biscuit perfection, or at least my version of it, wasn’t an instant success; it took a few dedicated attempts to truly nail them. Having had the distinct pleasure of dining at the Magnolia Table Restaurant in Waco and savoring their exquisite biscuits firsthand, I now confidently believe that my homemade versions mirror that authentic taste and texture. This personal validation, comparing my efforts directly to Joanna’s own standard, gives me great confidence that I’ve finally mastered the nuances of this beloved recipe, bringing the true Magnolia experience into my home kitchen.

The Baking Journey: A Review of Jojo’s Biscuits

Joanna Gaines’ Jojo’s Biscuits recipe is surprisingly straightforward, yielding biscuits that are incredibly fluffy and utterly heavenly. Despite the simplicity of the steps, my path to perfection involved a bit of a learning curve, offering valuable insights into the delicate balance required for truly exceptional homemade biscuits.

I must admit, my very first batch didn’t quite live up to the picture-perfect image adorning the cookbook’s pages. While they tasted undeniably delicious—warm, buttery, and comforting—my goal was aesthetic perfection. Like many home bakers, I aspired for them to replicate Joanna’s immaculate presentation. Unfortunately, this inaugural attempt resulted in biscuits that spread more than they rose, resembling what one might call a “drop biscuit” rather than the elegantly tall, layered creations I envisioned.

This initial outcome offered a crucial lesson: the dough was likely too wet. As the biscuits began to bake and the butter melted, the excess moisture caused them to spread outwards instead of achieving that coveted vertical lift. While not what I aimed for, these flatter, cake-like biscuits would have been absolutely ideal for the delightful Strawberry Shortcake recipe featured later in the same cookbook. Their tender texture and expansive surface would perfectly cradle fresh berries and dollops of whipped cream, demonstrating that even a “mistake” can find its perfect application.

My second batch represented a significant departure from the first. In an attempt to counteract the previous spreading, I overcompensated by adding too much extra flour. The result? Biscuits that reached for the sky, resembling adorable, albeit slightly rigid, “little top hats.” These tall, proud biscuits certainly achieved an impressive rise, but their texture was a tad drier than ideal. While still flavorful and soft to the bite, they lacked the ethereal fluffiness that makes Jojo’s Biscuits so renowned. This batch served as a stark contrast to my initial attempt, highlighting the delicate balance required in biscuit making—a culinary tightrope walk between too much moisture and too little.

It truly is true what they say: the third time’s the charm. My persistent quest for biscuit perfection finally bore fruit, thanks to a surprising revelation. The culprit behind my inconsistent results wasn’t my technique or ingredients, but rather a faulty measuring cup. Switching to a different, accurate 1-cup measure made an astonishing difference. (A word to the wise: if you’ve invested in the beautiful stainless steel and teak handled measuring cups from Magnolia, be aware that the 1-cup measure, in my experience, was two ounces short, subtly sabotaging my previous biscuit attempts!) This seemingly minor adjustment unlocked the true potential of the recipe, proving once again that precision is paramount in baking.

With all my measurements finally precise and accurate, the biscuits from my third attempt emerged from the oven in a state of absolute culinary bliss. They were truly heavenly and utterly perfect. They spread and rose exactly as Joanna describes in her cookbook, their edges gently touching as they baked in unison, creating those coveted soft, pulled-apart sides. The rise was magnificent, yielding beautifully layered, fluffy interiors and golden-brown exteriors that were a joy to behold and an even greater joy to taste. This batch was the culmination of my efforts, a triumphant moment that brought Joanna’s vision to life in my own kitchen.

Pro Tips for Perfecting Your Jojo’s Biscuits

Through my extensive experimentation, I’ve gathered some invaluable tips that can help you adapt Jojo’s Biscuits to various culinary needs. First, consider intentionally making your biscuit mixture a little wetter, perhaps by adding an extra ¼ cup of buttermilk. This slight modification will yield gorgeous, tender, cake-like biscuits, perfect for pairing with fresh strawberries and whipped cream. When baking these, arrange them apart on the baking sheet to encourage a beautiful dome shape. For serving, I prefer to hollow out the center slightly rather than slicing them in half, filling the cavity with berries and cream, replacing the top, and then adding more decadent toppings. This method creates a delightful, rustic presentation that enhances the overall experience.

Secondly, for those instances when you desire a biscuit with a bit more structure, ideal for soaking up rich gravies, try reducing the buttermilk by about ¼ cup. This adjustment will result in a slightly stiffer dough, leading to biscuits that are wonderfully sturdy without sacrificing flavor or tenderness. While my second batch, initially deemed an “overcompensation,” unintentionally demonstrated this variation, I now see it as a successful adaptation. These firmer biscuits held up magnificently under the weight of a savory gravy, absorbing every last drop exactly as you’d want a classic gravy biscuit to perform. It’s a testament to the versatility of this recipe, proving that even deviations can lead to delicious discoveries tailored to different dishes.

Perhaps the most significant tip I can offer, which I’ve found genuinely enhances the lightness of these biscuits, pertains to the incorporation of the egg. Instead of adding the egg separately, I beat it directly into my buttermilk before combining all the wet ingredients at once. I firmly believe this technique contributes to a lighter, more tender biscuit because it minimizes the amount of handling and working the flour. Excessive handling can develop the gluten too much, resulting in tougher biscuits. My initial attempts at mixing the egg in alone resulted in a gummy, less desirable texture. If any seasoned bakers or culinary experts have alternative insights or reasons why mixing the egg in first and separately might be superior, I would absolutely love to hear your thoughts and explanations in the comments below!

The Delicious Reaction: Serving and Enjoying Jojo’s Biscuits

In my culinary judgment, Jojo’s Biscuits truly represent the pinnacle of homemade perfection. They are the quintessential table biscuit, versatile enough to complement any topping your heart desires. Whether slathered with your favorite jam or jelly, these biscuits transform a simple breakfast or brunch into an extraordinary event. And if you’re feeling particularly indulgent, I highly recommend spreading a generous dollop of Nutella on a warm Jojo’s Biscuit—the combination is an absolute triumph of flavor and texture, a truly decadent experience that melts in your mouth!

For an authentic touch of Waco magic, imagine enjoying these fluffy delights with the famed Strawberry Butter you might have brought home from a visit to the Magnolia Table Restaurant. That creamy, sweet, and slightly tangy butter elevates Jojo’s Biscuits to an unparalleled level of gastronomic pleasure, making every bite a cherished memory.

Looking back at my entire baking adventure, I can confidently say that I loved all three versions of these biscuits, each offering its unique charm and application. The journey of trial and error has not only led me to master the ideal Jojo’s Biscuit but has also taught me how to intentionally adapt the recipe for different dishes and occasions. The versatility I’ve uncovered means I can now confidently bake the perfect biscuit for strawberry shortcake, a hearty gravy, or simply as a standalone accompaniment to coffee. And on that note, I absolutely cannot wait to whip up that delightful butter flight I’ve been planning ASAP—because what better way to celebrate perfect biscuits than with an array of delicious, complementary butters!

Until next time, happy cooking and happy baking!

Kendell

If you watched Joanna make this delightful recipe on Season 1, Episode 6 of her captivating cooking show, ‘Magnolia Table with Joanna Gaines‘, you’re in luck! She generously shared the official recipe on her blog, making it incredibly easy for you to recreate these culinary masterpieces at home. Simply CLICK HERE to access the recipe directly and start your own biscuit-making adventure!

–

Explore More Magnolia Table Delights: Read My Other Reviews from Episode 6 Here…

BoBo’s Classic (Sausage) Gravy

Strawberry Shortcake + Homemade Whipped Cream

Butter Flight (coming soon)

Farm Eggs Benedict (coming soon)

📖 Recipe: Homemade Self-Rising Flour

Did you try this recipe or have your own tips for Jojo’s Biscuits? Let me know by leaving a review or comment below! And for more delicious recipes, cooking adventures, and behind-the-scenes content, be sure to sign up for my newsletter. You can also follow along and connect with me on Instagram, Pinterest, and Facebook! I love hearing from you!