Grandma’s Classic Banana Split Cake: A Retro Dessert with a Controversial Twist

Journey back in time with this delightful, old-school Banana Split Cake recipe, lovingly unearthed from my grandmother’s cherished recipe book. This dessert isn’t just a treat; it’s a slice of nostalgia, reminiscent of simpler times and classic soda fountain delights. While it holds a fascinating, slightly controversial secret in its traditional preparation, I’m thrilled to share both the original method and a modern, optional adjustment. You get to choose your path, just like in the movies – will you embrace tradition or opt for a contemporary twist?

A delectable Banana Split Cake in a glass baking dish, with a couple of slices already removed, revealing the creamy layers. Fresh banana slices and a sprinkle of chopped pecans garnish the individual servings, ready to be enjoyed.

Regardless of whether you caught my subtle movie reference, the ultimate outcome of this recipe is guaranteed to be incredibly tasty and satisfying. It perfectly captures all the joyful flavors and visual appeal of a classic banana split, but with a unique and utterly delicious graham cracker crust that, in my opinion, makes it even better than its ice cream counterpart! For those eager to know, the “controversial” ingredient is indeed raw eggs, used in the traditional filling. We’ll delve deeper into that detail and offer a fantastic alternative as we go along, ensuring everyone can enjoy this retro masterpiece with confidence.

Jump to Recipe Card

Essential Ingredients for Your Banana Split Cake

When you glance at this ingredient list, you’ll immediately recognize all the beloved, traditionally delightful flavors of a classic banana split. The only missing element is the actual ice cream, which is brilliantly mimicked by our rich, creamy filling! Crushed pineapple and bright maraschino cherries are absolutely essential for that authentic banana split experience, contributing both flavor and vibrant color. However, you have the flexibility to customize the nuts to suit your personal preference. I find that toasted pecans add a wonderful depth and crunch to this particular recipe, but feel free to experiment with other favorites like salty peanuts, earthy walnuts, or even delicate hazelnuts – all would be equally delicious additions.

All the fresh ingredients meticulously laid out, ready to be transformed into a delicious Banana Split Cake, including ripe bananas, crushed pineapple, maraschino cherries, graham cracker crumbs, butter, powdered sugar, eggs, vanilla extract, and whipped topping.

The star of this dessert, the slightly sweet and wonderfully airy filling, is where the traditional raw eggs come into play, creating a texture that beautifully mimics melted ice cream. This luscious layer provides a perfect contrast to the crunchy crust and fruity toppings. To finish this spectacular dessert, a generous layer of whipped topping is spread over everything, just like the dollop of cream that crowns a traditional banana split. We’ll also discuss how to pick the best bananas for optimal flavor and texture, ensuring your cake is perfect every time. Remember, fresh, high-quality ingredients are the foundation of any outstanding dessert.

For precise ingredient measurements and step-by-step instructions, please use the JUMP TO RECIPE button at the top of this post, or simply scroll down to the bottom to find the full printable recipe card.

Crafting Your Delightful Banana Split Cake: Step-by-Step Guide

Let’s begin the exciting journey of assembling this iconic dessert! The first step involves creating and briefly baking our signature graham cracker crust. While some might consider a baked crust to disqualify it from being “no-bake,” I still largely consider this an almost no-bake dessert. The baking process for the crust is incredibly minimal; it merely involves mixing pre-packaged graham cracker crumbs with melted butter, pressing the mixture firmly into your baking pan, and then baking it for a mere 8 minutes. This short bake time is just enough to set the crust, preventing it from crumbling when you slice into your finished cake. In my book, such a brief stint in the oven doesn’t truly count as “baking” in the traditional sense, making this an exceptionally easy foundational layer.

Melted butter combined with graham cracker crumbs in a mixing bowl, ready to be pressed into the baking dish for the crust.

Firmly pressing the prepared graham cracker crust mixture into a 9x13 inch baking pan, ensuring an even and compact base for the cake.

Once your crust has finished its quick bake, it’s crucial to allow it to cool completely before proceeding. A warm crust can melt your creamy filling, compromising the cake’s structure. While the crust cools, it’s time to whip up the star of our show: the luscious filling. In a spacious mixing bowl, combine the softened butter, powdered sugar, vanilla extract, and, for the traditionalists, two large eggs. Beat these ingredients together using a stand mixer with a whip attachment until the mixture becomes wonderfully light, fluffy, and significantly increased in volume. Yes, you read that correctly – the original recipe’s filling is made with raw eggs. This method is perfectly acceptable and traditional, especially when using very fresh, high-quality eggs or farm-fresh eggs from a trusted source, as they carry a lower risk. The texture achieved with raw eggs is uniquely smooth and custard-like.

However, if the idea of raw eggs gives you pause, or if you’re preparing this for guests with dietary concerns, there’s an excellent and equally delicious alternative. Simply replace both the butter and the raw eggs in the filling step with an 8-ounce block of softened cream cheese. Whip the cream cheese with the powdered sugar and vanilla until smooth and creamy. This substitution provides a stable, tangy, and equally delightful filling without compromising on flavor or texture. Both versions yield a superb dessert, allowing you to choose the path that best suits your comfort level and preferences.

The process of making the creamy, fluffy filling in a stand mixer, combining butter, powdered sugar, vanilla, and eggs, to be spread over the graham cracker crust.

The perfectly whipped, light, and fluffy filling showcased in a stand mixer bowl, ready for layering into the Banana Split Cake.

With your filling prepared, spread it gently and evenly over the cooled graham cracker crust. This forms the delightful creamy base for your fruit layers. Next, generously top this filling with a layer of well-drained crushed pineapple, ensuring even distribution across the entire surface. The pineapple adds a burst of tangy sweetness and moisture. Follow this with a neatly arranged layer of freshly sliced bananas. For best results, slice your bananas just before adding them to prevent browning. Finally, finish off this glorious assembly with a thick, smooth layer of whipped topping. While you certainly can whip up your own fresh cream, Grandma, true to her practical nature, always opted for convenient store-bought frozen whipped topping – and it works beautifully, giving that authentic nostalgic flavor!

The final stages of assembling the Banana Split Cake: spreading out the crushed pineapple over the creamy filling, adding a fresh layer of sliced bananas, and then topping everything with a smooth layer of whipped cream.

The fully assembled Banana Split Cake in the baking dish, ready to be chilled. It's garnished with vibrant chopped maraschino cherries and a generous sprinkle of toasted pecans on top.

To achieve the best texture and allow all the flavors to meld perfectly, it’s essential to chill your Banana Split Cake for at least a couple of hours, or ideally, overnight. This chilling time ensures the filling sets properly and the layers become cohesive. I prefer to add the final garnishes – the chopped maraschino cherries and toasted pecans – after the cake has had some time to chill. The cherries, though visually appealing, tend to release a little liquid as they sit, which can slightly affect the pristine appearance of the topping. By adding them last, you maintain a fresher, more vibrant look. However, if you’re not overly concerned with presentation, feel free to top everything before chilling. When it’s time to serve, I like to elevate each slice further by adding a few fresh banana slices and an extra dusting of pecans, truly bringing home that authentic banana split experience.

Several slices of Banana Split Cake, beautifully plated and ready to eat, topped with fresh banana slices and a sprinkle of pecans, alongside the remaining cake in the baking dish.

Expert Notes & Tips for the Perfect Banana Split Cake

Creating this nostalgic Banana Split Cake is straightforward, but a few key tips can ensure your dessert is an absolute triumph. Pay close attention to these pointers, especially regarding the unique aspects of this traditional recipe.

Understanding the Raw Eggs: Yes, you are indeed reading the original recipe correctly – the creamy filling traditionally incorporates raw eggs. For those who choose to follow this classic method, it is absolutely paramount to use only super-fresh eggs that are free of any cracks or imperfections. Sourcing eggs from a local farm or a reputable producer known for fresh, high-quality products can further reduce any potential risks. This is a time-honored technique that yields a uniquely smooth and rich filling.
The Cream Cheese Alternative: If you or your guests are uncomfortable with consuming raw eggs, please rest assured that a fantastic and safe alternative is readily available. Simply replace the butter and eggs in the filling step with a single 8-ounce block of room-temperature cream cheese. Ensure the cream cheese is softened to achieve a perfectly smooth, lump-free mixture. Follow the remaining instructions as directed; this substitution will result in a slightly tangier yet equally delicious and stable filling.
Make-Ahead Convenience: This Banana Split Cake is an ideal make-ahead dessert! You can fully assemble the cake up to a day before you plan to serve it. This allows ample time for the flavors to fully meld and the cake to chill thoroughly, which is essential for its texture and stability. For the freshest appearance, wait to add the final garnishes – the nuts, cherries, and any additional fresh banana slices – just before you are ready to serve. This prevents the bananas from browning and keeps the cherries from releasing excess liquid onto the whipped topping.
Storage and Food Safety: If you opt for the traditional raw egg filling, I highly recommend consuming the cake within 3 days of making it. This is a crucial suggestion for optimal food safety and to ensure the highest quality and freshest taste. Always store any leftovers promptly in an airtight container in the refrigerator. Even with the cream cheese alternative, the cake is best enjoyed within 3-4 days for peak freshness.

Versatile Substitutions to Customize Your Banana Split Cake

One of the joys of cooking is the ability to adapt recipes to suit different tastes, dietary needs, or simply what you have on hand. This Banana Split Cake recipe is wonderfully flexible, allowing for several easy substitutions without sacrificing flavor.

Graham Cracker Crust Variations: I typically rely on store-bought graham cracker crumbs for their convenience and consistent texture. This also makes it incredibly easy to adapt the recipe for a gluten-free diet; simply opt for gluten-free graham cracker crumbs. If you can’t find pre-crushed gluten-free crumbs, don’t despair! Purchase gluten-free crackers and easily crush them yourself using a food processor for a fine texture, or place them in a zip-top bag and crush them with a rolling pin or the bottom of a heavy skillet. You could also experiment with other crumb bases like vanilla wafers or even chocolate cookie crumbs for a different flavor profile.
Raw Egg Alternative (Reiterated): As previously mentioned, if the inclusion of raw eggs in the filling makes you hesitant, a simple and delicious substitution is available. Replace the raw eggs and one stick of butter in the filling mixture with one 8-ounce block of softened cream cheese. This provides a rich, creamy, and completely safe alternative that still delivers on flavor and texture.
Fruit Topping Alternatives: While crushed pineapple is a staple of the classic banana split, my Grandma sometimes ventured into other fruit options. She would occasionally replace the crushed pineapple with an equal amount of strawberry pie filling. This works exceptionally well, adding a burst of sweet strawberry flavor that beautifully complements the bananas and still maintains that beloved “banana split” feel. You could also explore other fruit fillings like cherry or even a mixed berry compote, just ensure they are well-drained if they tend to be juicy.
Whipped Topping Options: The original recipe, like many classic desserts of its era, typically called for frozen whipped topping. This is a convenient and effective choice that provides a light, airy finish. However, if you prefer a homemade touch, you can easily whip up a couple of cups of heavy cream with powdered sugar, sweetened to your liking, to create your own luscious whipped cream. A touch of vanilla extract in your homemade whipped cream will enhance its flavor.
Nutty Finishes: Toasted pecans are my personal favorite and what I always remember Grandma using to top this cake. Their buttery, slightly crunchy texture and warm flavor are a perfect match for the sweet and creamy layers. However, this is another area where you can absolutely personalize your cake. Chopped peanuts, walnuts, or even hazelnuts would all make excellent substitutions, each offering a distinct flavor and texture that will enhance the overall experience. Lightly toasting any nuts before adding them will bring out their best flavor.

The chilled and perfectly set Banana Split Cake in its baking dish, garnished with cherries and pecans, ready to be sliced and served.

More Classic Recipes You’ll Love

If you’re a fan of timeless dishes and nostalgic flavors, be sure to explore these other classic recipes that are sure to bring comfort and joy to your kitchen:

Classic Caesar Salad
Easy Haystack Cookies
Quick Homemade Lasagna
Delightful Carrot Cake Cookies
Crispy Pork Schnitzel
Homemade Spaghettio’s with Meatballs
No-Bake Eclair Cake
Savory Potato Chip Chicken
Classic Homemade Sloppy Joe’s

Frequently Asked Questions About Banana Split Cake

Here are some common questions you might have about making and enjoying this classic Banana Split Cake:

Is this truly a “no-bake” cake?
While the filling and topping layers require no baking, the graham cracker crust is briefly baked for about 8 minutes. This short bake time is just enough to set the crust and give it stability, which helps prevent it from crumbling when you cut into the finished cake. Many consider it “almost no-bake” due to the minimal baking involved.
How long does Banana Split Cake last?
If made with the traditional raw egg filling, it’s best to consume the cake within 3 days for optimal food safety and freshness. If you use the cream cheese alternative, it can typically last for 3-4 days when stored properly in the refrigerator. Always keep leftovers covered tightly in an airtight container to maintain freshness.
Can I make this cake ahead of time for a party?
Absolutely! This cake is an excellent make-ahead dessert. You can assemble the entire cake, including all the layers, up to 24 hours in advance. This allows the cake ample time to chill and for the flavors to fully meld together. For the best presentation, it’s recommended to add the final garnishes (cherries, pecans, fresh banana slices) just before serving.
What kind of bananas should I use?
Choose ripe, but not overly ripe, bananas. They should be firm with a few brown spots, indicating sweetness without being mushy. Avoid green bananas, as they lack flavor, and overly brown bananas, as they can become too soft and darken quickly.
Why do I need to drain the crushed pineapple so well?
Draining the crushed pineapple thoroughly is crucial to prevent the cake from becoming watery or soggy. Excess liquid can seep into the layers, especially the crust, and negatively affect the cake’s texture and stability. You can press the pineapple in a fine-mesh sieve or blot it with paper towels.
Can I use homemade whipped cream instead of frozen whipped topping?
Yes, you certainly can! While the original recipe often uses frozen whipped topping for convenience and classic flavor, homemade whipped cream is a delicious alternative. Simply whip heavy cream with a bit of powdered sugar and vanilla extract to your desired sweetness and consistency.

Did you make this unforgettable Banana Split Cake recipe? I would absolutely love to hear about your experience! Please consider leaving a review or a comment below to share your thoughts. And don’t forget to sign up for my newsletter to get more delicious recipes delivered straight to your inbox. You can also follow along with all my culinary adventures on Instagram, Pinterest, and Facebook!

📖 Recipe

Yield: 12 servings

Banana Split Cake

Prep Time:
20 minutes

Cook Time:
8 minutes

Chilling Time:
2 hours

Total Time:
2 hours 28 minutes

This delightful Banana Split Cake recipe, inherited from my grandmother, offers a nostalgic taste of a classic dessert with a special, optional twist for its creamy filling. It’s easy to make and perfect for any occasion!

Ingredients

2 cups Graham Cracker Crumbs
16 tablespoons (2 sticks) Unsalted Butter, room temp
2 cups Powdered Sugar
1 tablespoon Vanilla Extract
2 large Eggs (see notes for alternative)
1, 20-ounce can Crushed Pineapple, well-drained
4 large Bananas, sliced
1, 8-ounce tub Frozen Whipped Topping, thawed
Maraschino Cherries, for garnish
Pecans, toasted and chopped, for garnish

Instructions

Preheat the oven to 350˚F (175°C).

Melt one stick of butter in the microwave or on the stovetop until fully liquid.

In a medium bowl, combine the graham cracker crumbs and melted butter. Stir thoroughly until the crumbs are evenly moistened.

Press the crumb mixture firmly and evenly into the bottom of a 9×13 inch baking pan to form the crust.

Bake in the preheated oven for 8 minutes to set the crust. Remove from oven and let it cool completely on a wire rack.

To make the filling: In the bowl of a stand mixer, combine the remaining stick of softened butter, powdered sugar, vanilla extract, and eggs. Beat with the whip attachment on medium-high speed for about 3 minutes, until the mixture is light, fluffy, and well combined. (For the raw egg-free alternative, replace butter and eggs with 8 oz softened cream cheese and whip until smooth).

Pour the prepared filling mixture over the completely cooled crust and spread it into an even layer.

Carefully top the filling layer with the well-drained crushed pineapple, spreading it evenly. Then, arrange the sliced bananas in a single layer over the pineapple.

Gently cover the banana layer with the thawed whipped topping, spreading it smoothly to cover all the fruit.

For a beautiful finish, sprinkle chopped toasted pecans over the whipped topping and artfully place maraschino cherries on top.

Refrigerate the cake for at least 2 hours (or ideally, overnight) before serving, allowing it to chill thoroughly and set. Store any leftovers in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 3 days.

Notes

Notes & Tips

Yes, you are reading the recipe right. The filling includes raw eggs. Just be sure to use super-fresh eggs that have no cracks in them.

If you prefer not to use raw eggs, replace the butter and eggs in the filling step with an 8-ounce block of room-temperature cream cheese. Follow the remaining instructions.

The cake can be made up to a day before you plan to eat it and finished with the nuts, cherries, and more bananas just before serving.

I suggest consuming the cake within 3 days of making it if you use the raw eggs. This is a suggestion for food safety and to keep anyone from getting sick.

Substitutions

I usually use store-bought graham cracker crumbs for this recipe. This allows you to also make it gluten-free if you need to. If you can not locate gluten-free crumbs, purchase gluten-free crackers and crush them in a food processor or in a zip-top bag and crush them with a rolling pin or skillet.

As mentioned above, replace the raw eggs and 1 stick of butter with an 8-ounce block of cream cheese if you can’t bring yourself to eat raw eggs.

Grandma sometimes replaced the crushed pineapple with strawberry pie filling. This works equally well and still keeps that banana-split feel.

Frozen whipped topping is what this classic recipe was always made with. You could also whip up a couple of cups of heavy cream with some powdered sugar sweetened to your liking to replace it.

Toasted pecans are what I always remember Grandma putting on this cake. But peanuts, walnuts, or hazelnuts would even be great.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Instagram

Ultimate Banana Split Cake